New York › Suffolk County
11964 Shelter Island, NY: can you afford to buy or rent here?
Zillow data through Oct 2026.
Open 11964 in the interactive map
Can you afford it?
Income to buy comfortably
$475K/yr
$1.82M home, 20% down ($364K), 7.28% rate; housing ≤ 28% of income
Income to rent
$144K/yr
40× the $3,610 monthly rent
Local median household income
$135K/yr
Census ACS
Enter your own income and savings to see which ZIPs fit you.
Key numbers
Typical home value
$1.82M
+6.2% year over year
Typical rent
$3,610/mo
HUD Fair Market Rent (low confidence)
Gross rental yield
2.38%
Annual rent ÷ value
Price-to-rent ratio
42
Years of rent to equal the price
5-yr value growth
+6.8%/yr
Zillow ZHVI
County job growth
+2.1%/yr
BLS QCEW
Property tax (new buyer)
0.51%
What recent buyers pay, Census ACS
By bedrooms
| Beds | Typical value | Rent | Price-to-rent | Gross yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 bed | — | $2,760 | — | — |
| 2 beds | $1.14M | $3,610 | 26.2 | 3.81% |
| 3 beds | $1.53M | $4,600 | 27.8 | 3.60% |
| 4 beds | $2.28M | $5,630 | 33.7 | 2.97% |
| 5+ beds | $3.85M | $7,160 | 44.8 | 2.23% |
Rents by bedroom are estimates except where Zillow or listing data exists.
Natural hazard risk
Flooding: Moderate · Coastal flooding: High · Wildfire: Low · Hurricane: Moderate · Earthquake: Low · Tornado: Low
FEMA National Risk Index, combined from census tracts.
Rent rules
Some cities have local rent control (no statewide cap); check the city's rules before buying.